Sea of Thieves Season 16 Weapon Tier List: Best Picks for PvP and PvE Combat

• Author
• Recent Posts

Valencia

Guide Curator at GladiatorBoost

I’m the voice behind the blogs here at GladiatorBoost—diving deep into the gaming world to bring you guides, updates, and stories that actually help (and maybe even entertain a little). Whether it's breaking down the latest boosts or highlighting cool moments in your favorite games, I’m here to make the digital grind a little more fun.

Latest posts by Valencia (see all)

Season 16 of Sea of Thieves is well underway, and with it comes a fresh look at the weapon meta. Whether you’re sword-fighting skeletons on a cursed isle or sniping rival pirates during an intense PvP clash, your weapon loadout can make or break the encounter. With only two slots to equip, choosing the right tools is more critical than ever.

This guide delivers a detailed breakdown of the best weapons in Sea of Thieves for Season 16, ranked from S to C-tier based on their performance, ease of use, and value in different combat situations. Whether you’re boarding enemy ships or defending your loot, we’ve got the rankings—and the strategies—to give you the edge.

⚔️ Sea of Thieves Weapon Tier List – Season 16

🥇 S-Tier: Eye of Reach – The Undisputed Champion

If you’re looking for the strongest weapon in Sea of Thieves, the Eye of Reach reigns supreme in Season 16. This precision rifle-style weapon deals massive damage from range and rewards skilled aiming with deadly efficiency.

Why It Dominates:

• Devastating single-shot power

• Superior long-range control

• Perfect for PvP and PvE

• Excellent combo with melee weapons like the Cutlass

Pro Tip: Its slow reload is its only drawback, so pair it with a fast melee weapon or use cover to stay protected between shots.

🥈 A-Tier: Reliable Weapons for Versatile Playstyles

These weapons may not hit S-tier levels, but they remain highly competitive and are favorites for many players in both PvP and PvE.

Cutlass

The quintessential pirate weapon. No ammo required, fast swings, and reliable lunge mobility.

• Pros:

  • Always available

  • Doesn’t require reloading

  • High skill ceiling with combo potential

• Use it for: Close-quarters fights, boarding ships, or breaking blocks in melee skirmishes.

Blade of Souls

This fiery melee weapon turns every swing into chaos. It ignites enemies and knocks them back, applying pressure through burn damage.

• Pros:

  • Adds fire-based damage over time

  • Knockback disrupts enemy rhythm

  • Reward for defeating the Burning Blade world event

• Note: Must be physically carried and can’t be stored like traditional weapons.

Flintlock

The most balanced gun in the game, offering consistent mid-range damage and faster reload than other firearms.

• Pros:

  • Doesn’t rely on ADS

  • Great reload speed

  • Reliable for all skill levels

• Ideal for: Pirates who want a dependable sidearm that shines in chaotic mid-range fights.

🟡 B-Tier: Niche Picks with Playable Potential

These weapons can still be effective but require specific situations, skill, or combos to truly shine.

Throwing Knives

Excellent for quick, silent takedowns—especially effective when retrieved post-throw.

Blunderbuss

Great for knocking enemies off ladders, decks, and boats. Up close, it can be brutal.

Blowpipe & Double Barrel Pistol

Both offer unique playstyles, but suffer from inconsistent damage output or reload speed. Useful in creative hands, but not meta-defining.

🔴 C-Tier: Use with Caution

These tools are often more fun than functional. While they may serve a purpose in rare situations, they’re generally outclassed by better options.

Examples:

• Hunting Spear: Cool but clunky

• Grapple Gun: Great for mobility, not for damage

• Blunderbombs/Tridents: Better used as support than primary weapons

They can serve you well during exploration or wild moments, but in a tight PvP fight? Pick something else.

⚓ Top PvP Loadouts in Season 16

Your success in PvP hinges on weapon synergy. Here are a few recommended combos:

• Eye of Reach + Cutlass: Sniping precision + close-range defense

• Flintlock + Throwing Knives: Mid-range power with sneaky finish potential

• Blunderbuss + Cutlass: Push enemies off ships, then finish them fast

Choose weapons that cover both melee and ranged threats to keep your options open during unpredictable engagements.

💡 Sea of Thieves Meta Influencers

Why some weapons rise (or fall) in value:

• Game updates and balance patches tweak damage, reload speeds, or mechanics.

• Environment shifts: Weapon viability changes with new map locations, tighter spaces, or open waters.

• Skill evolution: Weapons like Eye of Reach reward aim and discipline—perfect for veteran players.

• New seasons and weapons introduce experimental tools that disrupt the meta.

🚀 Boost Your Progress with GladiatorBoost

Dominating with the best weapons means more than just equipping them—it means earning commendations, unlocking cosmetics, and farming PvP levels. If you’re tired of the grind or want a shortcut to high-tier rewards, Sea of Thieves Boosting services from GladiatorBoost are here to help.

Popular Services Include:

• Guardians of Fortune PvP Boost

• Ghost Curse Unlock

• PvP Level Farming

• Skeleton Curse Challenges

With fast, secure completion and highly experienced boosters, GladiatorBoost helps you enjoy the thrill of competition without the time sink.

🏴‍☠️ Final Thoughts

Season 16 brings plenty of mayhem to the seas—but the right weapon makes all the difference. Whether you’re sniping from the crow’s nest with Eye of Reach or cleaving through foes with your trusty Cutlass, understanding the current meta helps you stay one step ahead.

Always remember:

• Choose based on your combat style

• Balance range and melee

• Adapt with the meta changes

Sea of Thieves rewards creativity and combat awareness. So grab your gear, pick your tools wisely, and become a legend of the sea.